222 posts
Favorite Level: Saturn V by nasgubb
Hardest Demon: Bloodbath by Riot
Mini-Profile Background: ffffff
Mini-Profile Name Color: 000000
|
Post by Geometry Dash Chaoz on Dec 19, 2015 16:32:41 GMT -5
This is my newest level. Some say it's 10/10, others say it's 6/10, don't know what to believe. Anyways, info below, enjoy! ID: 14988175 Recommended rating: Hard 4/5 Stars Video (a bit unsynced): everyplay.com/videos/23812260Hope you enjoy! |
|
396 posts
Mini-Profile Background: {"image":"","color":"1d81bf"}
Mini-Profile Name Color: 1c2833
Mini-Profile Text Color: aed6f1
|
Post by Cheeseman on Dec 19, 2015 16:33:51 GMT -5
That may or may not have been me |
|
|
|
Post by Omega on Dec 19, 2015 16:46:34 GMT -5
Awesome level!
Boring in beginning
Love the ball part
the drop is boring. 7.3/10
|
|
|
|
Post by Mechanguis on Dec 19, 2015 20:51:27 GMT -5
Gameplay: Pretty good. No bugs, annoying moving obstacles, no invisible portals. There was also a wide variety of vehicles used to keep the gameplay interesting. That being said, the first ship/UFO part felt a bit repetitive since it felt like you were going through the same obstacle, just in different places.
Decoration/Design: Truth be told, I don't really like the design of this level. Some of the colors, especially in the last wave/ball part, looked too saturated. I also didn't really like how there wasn't much foreground deco in the ball parts, and all the deco was in the custom BG. The use of the rainbow in the first ship/ufo segment didn't really fit in well with the design of that part.
Music Sync: Really good. The decorations were synced, the flashes were synced, the transitions were synced, the jumps were synced. A+.
Overall: The gameplay and music sync were spot-on in this level, but the design of the level just looked weird to me. Especially in the last wave/cube/ball segment, some of the colors were too saturated and looked awkward with the BG. Good.
|
|
|
|
Post by Viceroy on Dec 19, 2015 21:03:22 GMT -5
Honestly I'd call this decent.
Decoration: 4/10
It was good to start off, then it really took a sheer drop towards the end, and in the middle.
Colors started clashing, stuff got messy...
Gameplay: 6/10
I don't like the ball part with the orb spam. At all.
The rest of the gameplay was just average.
Music Sync: 7/10
Not bad I guess.
5.6666667/10
Decent, I think.
|
|
222 posts
Favorite Level: Saturn V by nasgubb
Hardest Demon: Bloodbath by Riot
Mini-Profile Background: ffffff
Mini-Profile Name Color: 000000
|
Post by Geometry Dash Chaoz on Dec 20, 2015 5:33:06 GMT -5
Honestly I'd call this decent. Decoration: 4/10 It was good to start off, then it really took a sheer drop towards the end, and in the middle. Colors started clashing, stuff got messy... Gameplay: 6/10 I don't like the ball part with the orb spam. At all. The rest of the gameplay was just average. Music Sync: 7/10 Not bad I guess. 5.6666667/10 Decent, I think. First off, this level was focused on music sync. You can't give it 7/10 because "not bad" when everyone says it shines at this aspect the most. Second of all, explain why gameplay is 6/10? Gameplay points should be removed for bugs, glitches, etc. You can't remove half the score just because your didn't like 10% of it, even tho it was smooth. What problems did it have? Third of all, there are 2 reviews with "good" result and you are the only one with "decent" and still move it to decent, why? Forth, your review is really short and didn't explain well the final score. Fifth, you wanted to give it decent and you couldn't by giving it a very low "aspect" score so you decided to remove from other categories: music sync, gameplay (without explaining because you couldn't). What kind of review us this? You shouldn't have reduced other scores and instant move it just because you thought this is decent. |
|
222 posts
Favorite Level: Saturn V by nasgubb
Hardest Demon: Bloodbath by Riot
Mini-Profile Background: ffffff
Mini-Profile Name Color: 000000
|
Post by Geometry Dash Chaoz on Dec 20, 2015 5:44:08 GMT -5
/summon megaman9 Could you give this the final score? |
|
769 posts
Favorite Level: Asmyetry
Hardest Demon: ff0000
Mini-Profile Background: ff0000
Mini-Profile Name Color: {"image":"","color":"960c0c"}
|
Post by chocothep1e on Dec 20, 2015 8:11:02 GMT -5
Honestly I'd call this decent. Decoration: 4/10 It was good to start off, then it really took a sheer drop towards the end, and in the middle. Colors started clashing, stuff got messy... Gameplay: 6/10 I don't like the ball part with the orb spam. At all. The rest of the gameplay was just average. Music Sync: 7/10 Not bad I guess. 5.6666667/10 Decent, I think. I agree with this. Maybe the score is a bit lower to me, but I agree with this. 5 even seems good to me. Idk if I'm supposed to move or not, so I won't move to decent. But thats what I think it is. |
|
|
|
Post by Viceroy on Dec 20, 2015 11:00:04 GMT -5
Honestly I'd call this decent. Decoration: 4/10 It was good to start off, then it really took a sheer drop towards the end, and in the middle. Colors started clashing, stuff got messy... Gameplay: 6/10 I don't like the ball part with the orb spam. At all. The rest of the gameplay was just average. Music Sync: 7/10 Not bad I guess. 5.6666667/10 Decent, I think. First off, this level was focused on music sync. You can't give it 7/10 because "not bad" when everyone says it shines at this aspect the most. Second of all, explain why gameplay is 6/10? Gameplay points should be removed for bugs, glitches, etc. You can't remove half the score just because your didn't like 10% of it, even tho it was smooth. What problems did it have? Third of all, there are 2 reviews with "good" result and you are the only one with "decent" and still move it to decent, why? Forth, your review is really short and didn't explain well the final score. Fifth, you wanted to give it decent and you couldn't by giving it a very low "aspect" score so you decided to remove from other categories: music sync, gameplay (without explaining because you couldn't). What kind of review us this? You shouldn't have reduced other scores and instant move it just because you thought this is decent. Not trying to start up a fight here, but I didn't like it much, sorry. The level suggestions board is all about constructive criticism, and opinions may differ.  I don't think this is a good level, mostly because parts of it are just plain ugly. Mainly the end part. The music sync does kinda suck in some parts (the end) and the first ball. The gameplay wasn't exactly smooth in my opinion (first ufo/ship was repetitive, end, first ball) In order to get a high gameplay score from me, it needs to be pretty excellent. Like I said, it just felt generic and boring. Nothing too special. But again, don't wan't to start a fight. My apologies if I offended you  megaman9 Arbitrate this. EDIT: forgot to mention, levels aren't rated based on gameplay and music sync. If you have the most amazing, fun, synced level in the world, but it only uses the first block in the editor, there is no chance whatsoever of it geting rated. Just sayin. |
|
222 posts
Favorite Level: Saturn V by nasgubb
Hardest Demon: Bloodbath by Riot
Mini-Profile Background: ffffff
Mini-Profile Name Color: 000000
|
Post by Geometry Dash Chaoz on Dec 20, 2015 14:25:57 GMT -5
First off, this level was focused on music sync. You can't give it 7/10 because "not bad" when everyone says it shines at this aspect the most. Second of all, explain why gameplay is 6/10? Gameplay points should be removed for bugs, glitches, etc. You can't remove half the score just because your didn't like 10% of it, even tho it was smooth. What problems did it have? Third of all, there are 2 reviews with "good" result and you are the only one with "decent" and still move it to decent, why? Forth, your review is really short and didn't explain well the final score. Fifth, you wanted to give it decent and you couldn't by giving it a very low "aspect" score so you decided to remove from other categories: music sync, gameplay (without explaining because you couldn't). What kind of review us this? You shouldn't have reduced other scores and instant move it just because you thought this is decent. Not trying to start up a fight here, but I didn't like it much, sorry. The level suggestions board is all about constructive criticism, and opinions may differ. I don't think this is a good level, mostly because parts of it are just plain ugly. Mainly the end part. The music sync does kinda suck in some parts (the end) and the first ball. The gameplay wasn't exactly smooth in my opinion (first ufo/ship was repetitive, end, first ball) In order to get a high gameplay score from me, it needs to be pretty excellent. Like I said, it just felt generic and boring. Nothing too special. But again, don't wan't to start a fight. My apologies if I offended you megaman9 Arbitrate this. EDIT: forgot to mention, levels aren't rated based on gameplay and music sync. If you have the most amazing, fun, synced level in the world, but it only uses the first block in the editor, there is no chance whatsoever of it geting rated. Just sayin. Sorry if I was a bit rude in my review of your review, but from what you wrote (very short) there is very small amount of actual reviewing (eg. gameplay "didn't like the ball part and rest is average" and music sync "not bad") and so you didn't explain the actual score. In last ball part, it was about the exact same sync as the rest, what did you mean? (pulses are on-sync). |
|
|
|
Post by Viceroy on Dec 20, 2015 14:29:56 GMT -5
Not trying to start up a fight here, but I didn't like it much, sorry. The level suggestions board is all about constructive criticism, and opinions may differ. I don't think this is a good level, mostly because parts of it are just plain ugly. Mainly the end part. The music sync does kinda suck in some parts (the end) and the first ball. The gameplay wasn't exactly smooth in my opinion (first ufo/ship was repetitive, end, first ball) In order to get a high gameplay score from me, it needs to be pretty excellent. Like I said, it just felt generic and boring. Nothing too special. But again, don't wan't to start a fight. My apologies if I offended you megaman9 Arbitrate this. EDIT: forgot to mention, levels aren't rated based on gameplay and music sync. If you have the most amazing, fun, synced level in the world, but it only uses the first block in the editor, there is no chance whatsoever of it geting rated. Just sayin. Sorry if I was a bit rude in my review of your review, but from what you wrote (very short) there is very small amount of actual reviewing (eg. gameplay "didn't like the ball part and rest is average" and music sync "not bad") and so you didn't explain the actual score. In last ball part, it was about the exact same sync as the rest, what did you mean? (pulses are on-sync). Well yeah, the pulses are on-sync. But the gameplay not so much. Man, Megaman needs to hurry up and get in here already. |
|
|
|
Post by Mechanguis on Dec 22, 2015 3:04:31 GMT -5
|
|
89 posts
Discord: Matttopia
Creator Points: 8
Favorite Level: Scent by Optical
Hardest Demon: ffffff
Mini-Profile Background: ffffff
Mini-Profile Name Color: {"image":"https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/564x/80/ae/c3/80aec39cd6b4f331bcbedce6556eee1c.jpg","color":""}
|
Post by Matttopia on Dec 22, 2015 17:15:44 GMT -5
Not trying to start up a fight here, but I didn't like it much, sorry. The level suggestions board is all about constructive criticism, and opinions may differ. I don't think this is a good level, mostly because parts of it are just plain ugly. Mainly the end part. The music sync does kinda suck in some parts (the end) and the first ball. The gameplay wasn't exactly smooth in my opinion (first ufo/ship was repetitive, end, first ball) In order to get a high gameplay score from me, it needs to be pretty excellent. Like I said, it just felt generic and boring. Nothing too special. But again, don't wan't to start a fight. My apologies if I offended you megaman9 Arbitrate this. EDIT: forgot to mention, levels aren't rated based on gameplay and music sync. If you have the most amazing, fun, synced level in the world, but it only uses the first block in the editor, there is no chance whatsoever of it geting rated. Just sayin. Sorry if I was a bit rude in my review of your review, but from what you wrote (very short) there is very small amount of actual reviewing (eg. gameplay "didn't like the ball part and rest is average" and music sync "not bad") and so you didn't explain the actual score. In last ball part, it was about the exact same sync as the rest, what did you mean? (pulses are on-sync). Why can't you just be happy with your score and appreciate that people took the time to look and review your level? You don't need to criticize the judges to try and get a better score. Just be happy with your score and try to achieve better in the future. |
|
2,322 posts
Hardest Demon: Blue
Mini-Profile Name Color: {"image":"http://freedesignfile.com/upload/2014/07/Shiny-eco-style-green-background-vector-01.jpg","color":""}
|
Post by ~Pear~ on Dec 22, 2015 20:48:08 GMT -5
Sorry if I was a bit rude in my review of your review, but from what you wrote (very short) there is very small amount of actual reviewing (eg. gameplay "didn't like the ball part and rest is average" and music sync "not bad") and so you didn't explain the actual score. In last ball part, it was about the exact same sync as the rest, what did you mean? (pulses are on-sync). Why can't you just be happy with your score and appreciate that people took the time to look and review your level? You don't need to criticize the judges to try and get a better score. Just be happy with your score and try to achieve better in the future. agree, just take the feedback and try to make it better. dont try to bump ur score |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 23, 2015 2:01:35 GMT -5
Should this be moved to decent? megaman9 |
|
