Judges ReviewsKerby Boi
JUDGE FLOZO
Overall Impression:
Overall a very solid layout. I'd like to appreciate the sync involved. I'd personally recommend a faster speed, just due to the degree of the song, but with the current speed it still leads for a quite spectacular layout.
Sync:
- Spider was a bit off sync imo.
Gameplay Variety:
+ I love the gameplay variety in this. Especially at the drop. Possibly a variety of size portals could've been used in the beginning during the long cube section, but overall good job!
Appeal:
+ Cube looks very fun with its orb "spam", but it really isn't orb spam.
- The ship part looks a little boring,
- The robot as well (with the arrow orb). That could've been turned into a more dynamic dual with a ship traveling as well possibly falling into gravity portals.
Unique Aspects:
None really seen
Bugs:
Some places where it MAYBE could happen, but not really.
Judge Flozo's Rating:
Sync (8/10)
Variance (8.5/10)
Appeal (9/10)
Unique aspects (+0)
Bugs (-0)
JUDGE DSHIFTERI saw syncing problems in the spider and the wave into ufo, the ufo into ship didnt look too fun, but everything else was synced good and it generally looked fun.
Judge DShifter's Rating:
Sync (8/10)
Gameplay Variety (8.5/10)
Appeal/Is it fun? (8.5/10)
Unique aspects (+0)
Bugs (possibly, but would be very rare. -0)
JUDGE KASTUOverall Impression:
Overall seems enjoyable. The sync isn't anything mindblowing, but it is just right. The layout flows for its speed, but I'd wish it would've been faster.
Sync:
+ The sync for the first five seconds was pretty well executed.
- The spider part wasn't really synced much, excluding the two orbs.
- The robot part could have had something added to make it sync better as well.
Gameplay Variety:
+ Every gamemode is utilized, and most used efficiently as well. The teleportals are used as good transitions as well.
Appeal:
+ The first cube looks really fun and appealing, and almost looks timing based as well, which is a fun factor to learn.
- The wave transition from the teleportal doesn't exactly look fun to play over and over.
+ Although short, a lot of things strike me positively in the UFO section after the spider. The structures are good compared to the others, the gameplay itself and it's subtle sync.
- The ship and robot afterwards don't seem that fun or appealing.
Unique Aspects:
Nothing that really stands out.
Bugs:
There could be bugs, but you'd definitely have to search for them extra hard.
Judge Katsu's Rating:
Sync (8/10)
Variance (8/10)
Appeal (7/10)
Unique aspects (+0)
Bugs (-0)
Bl3ze's Score:
Sync (8/10)
Gameplay Variety (8.33/10)
Appeal (8.16/10)
Unique Aspects (+0)
Bugs (-0)
Bl3ze's Overall Score:
24.49/30
___________________________________________________AngelZXJUDGE FLOZOOverall Impression:
A very solid layout. I love the speed, really fits the theme of the music. The sync and variety of different game modes adds to this chaotic theme of the song.
Sync:
+ Orbs in first cube part sync nicely to music
- The platform with two cubes and one cube right after one block above is not in sync. I'd recommend moving the second cube to next to the third cube cuz the fall is a bit late.
+ Ball executed well with each tap being well synced to the music
- Second part of the spider doesn't really sync
- Wave doesn't sync
Variance:
+ Size Portal and Speed use right before drop
+ All Gameplay Portals during the drop
- The end wave is a bit boring, especially with the green arrow orb
Appeal:
+ First cube looks very enjoyable kudos to you
+ Holding of Ship looks fun, and makes the player feel good about themself with them flying through such a tight space so consistently
- Spider part looks a bit cancerous
- Wave part looks a bit cancerous, especially with the tight spam
Unique Aspects:
None really...
Bugs:
The Green Arrow Orb might be really hard to hit consistently (-0.5)
Judge Flozo's Rating:
Sync (8/10)
Variance (9/10)
Appeal (8.5/10)
Unique aspects (+0)
Bugs (-0.5)
JUDGE DSHIFTEROverall Impression:
Overall a good layout. Could've been a bit better in terms of playability, but looks all right.
Sync:
+Orbs are synced nicely in the beginning
-In the cube section, the bigger platform to the smaller one doesn't sync
+The flow from the ball holding into the ship feels nice.
-Second Spider doesn't sync, its one beat too early.
-Wave doesn't necessarily sync.
Gameplay Variance:
+All gamemodes are used, and effectively.
-Size portals are used for sync at drop. This is extremely overused in today's levels and thus can be irritating to play over and over again. I'd recommend two pink jump pads and then move the level up a few blocks.
-The small straight-fly right before the second spider can be irritating to play over and over again
-The wave at the end looks extremely difficult, even for someone who's practiced it.
+Overall the gameplay looks fun except for the couple parts.
Appeal:
+First cube is phenominal.
+Holding of ship after the ball section feels smooth and good.
-The wave at the doesn't appeal to people who want to play a 6-7 star level, it looks extremely difficult.
Unique Aspects:
Nothing much, the cube right before the drop is good but its nothing special.
Bugs:
None that I can see, but gameplay can be improved to back up the no-bug policy of the level.
Judge DShifter's Rating:
Sync (8.5/10)
Gameplay Variance (9/10)
Appeal (8/10) This would be higher, but that wave spam at the end doesn't look too friendly.
Unique Aspects (+0)
Bugs (-0)
AngelZX's Score:
Sync (8.25/10)
Gameplay Variety (9/10)
Appeal (8.25/10)
Unique Aspects (+0)
Bugs (-0.25)
AngelZX's Overall Score
25.25/30
___________________________________________________jettjamesJUDGE DSHIFTERSync:
-Cube orb spam at the beginning syncs for the most part, but the parts that don't sync really tear this section apart.
+Size Portals are NOT used for sync at drop, this is what I like to see.
-Transition to the wave isn't synced well.
+Ufo is synced decently
+Spider sync made me kreygasm, this is good.
-Cube into robot isn't synced at all
+Robot orb spam is synced well
Gameplay Variety:
+Most gamemodes are used
+Nothing is too hard, the straight fly looks 60hz managable, especially with the 1.5 block gap.
Appeal:
+Looks good to me. Pretty much your average level.
-The wave to UFO looks a tad weird, nothing to penalize much for though.
Unique Aspects:
Nothing really.
Bugs:
I could see a potential bug at the drop where the cube could hit the block instead of the pad...
Along with in the wave to UFO you could die from clipping in the slopes, because you get bigger from the wave to the UFO. ToshDeluxe has a video where he died on Allegiance from a wave to ball bug
Judge DShifter's Rating:
Sync (7.5/10)
Gameplay Variety (8.5/10)
Appeal (8/10)
Unique Aspects (+0)
Bugs (-0.5)
JUDGE KATSUOverall Impression:
Meh. It's a good start, is my overall impression.
Sync:
- Some of the cube doesn't sync, and it overpowers the moments it does sync.
- The ship/wave adds variety but doesn't really sync.
+ The UFO is actually subtly synced in terms of when you click, so it's alright.
+ Admittedly, the spider part is pretty well synced.
+ The orbs you click as a robot are well synced as well.
Gameplay Variety:
+ Most gamemodes are utilized.
- The robot at the end however wasn't used for its specific purpose, rather just to click orbs which a normal cube could've done.
Appeal:
- No real block structures, and most of the spikes are on the ground or just floating.
+ The green orb in the ship is a nice gamemode trick.
+ Although I don't seem to be a fan of it visually, the gameplay in the UFO is something I personally thing looks enjoyable, even if a bit spammy.
Unique Aspects:
None to note.
Bugs:
- A possible bug could be present at the cube transition to the first ship, due to the placement of the jump pad. As well as there could be a bug in the first moments of the UFO.
Judge Katsu's Rating:
Sync (6.5/10)
Variance (7/10)
Appeal (6/10)
Unique aspects (+0)
Bugs (-0.5)
Jett James's Score:
Sync (7/10)
Gameplay Variety (7.75/10)
Appeal (7/10)
Unique Aspects (+0)
Bugs (-0.5)
Jett James's Overall Score
21.25/30
___________________________________________________RESULTS (Judges)1.
AngelZX (25.25/30)
2.
Kerby Boi (24.49/30)
3.
jettjames (21.25/30)
POPULAR VOTE1.
AngelZX Kerby Boi jettjames all 0 likes (welp)
