|
|
Post by durianhead on May 23, 2017 6:11:24 GMT -5
everyone's part is so typical of their style, especially dudex's part that i got bored and closed the video after dudex because i can accurately predict what every part would look like. since i havent seen anything related to this collab because i dont follow evw shit too much than guess that rustam will have art of some kind of head over blocky structures and knobbelboy will have rainbows everywhere and vlacc and hinds will do their usual shit again lmao 4/10 would not play pls go out of comfort zone creators try something different Most.....generic critique ever. You don't just tell someone to start a new style. It's like telling Optical to stop making Modernistic levels when he's good at making the designs. That's not really constructive criticism by just saying, "Yep. Knobbel has his rainbows. Rustam has his art. Terrible level because there's nothing new." 1) im not calling the level terrible. anyone who thinks that that last sentence was anything but a joke is pretty dumb lol. i will concede that it was a pretty poorly executed joke on my expense. i'm only saying the level has creators who build the exact same thing for every part they make. look at dudex's, hinds' or vlacc's part for example and compare it to their parts in other collabs or other levels. after seeing the same thing so many times, one can only kinda get bored when i see effectively the same part here. 2) "It's like telling Optical to stop making Modernistic levels when he's good at making the designs." this isnt on the same league as rustam or dudex yet. optical makes unique things from his style and each of his levels are explorations on what he can do with modernism. people like dudex have nearly the exact same structures, block design, glow style and colour combinations for every level / level part lol 3) by using the word """generic""" to describe my critique, it kinda proves you have no idea what the word means and are just using for the sake of using it. since i can logically assume you are using the term generic in a negative and derogatory light, the definition of generic in that context is "lacking imagination or individuality, and being predictable or unoriginal". looking at the comments on this thread, im the only one who has raised this complaint, valid or not. thus my critique is the very ANTHITHESIS of generic. we can say on the other hand, using this definition, that, for example, "featured levels are generic", or dare i say, "every dudex, hinds or rustam collab part is generic." in conclusion, i dont think most of these creators made a bad level. i think most of these creators just made parts that didnt fully explore the limitations of their styles. im not saying that the level is bad or that the creators are bad or that the parts are bad because of a lack of originality. neither am i saying that everyone is unoriginal here. aquatius's part was pretty sweet honestly and its something i've never seen from him before. i'm just saying that if the creators here had pulled an Optical and fully explored the depth of their styles, this collab would have been so much better. until then lets agree to disagree. |
|
|
|
Post by durianhead on May 23, 2017 6:13:57 GMT -5
Most.....generic critique ever. You don't just tell someone to start a new style. It's like telling Optical to stop making Modernistic levels when he's good at making the designs. That's not really constructive criticism by just saying, "Yep. Knobbel has his rainbows. Rustam has his art. Terrible level because there's nothing new." And I add art when it is requested which is 90% of the time dOUBLE pOST you're a cool dude and all and i more have problems with your block design than with your art in terms of originality. still happy you stopped using that skull everywhere lol. no time to explain but maybe change up your block design a bit...? will expound more later no tiiiiime |
|
|
|
Post by Navianya on May 23, 2017 6:19:48 GMT -5
Nothing really stands out to me :/
|
|
769 posts
Mini-Profile Background: {"image":"http://orig02.deviantart.net/285d/f/2016/287/2/1/sugary_space_by_star_abraham-daj88p4.png","color":""}
Mini-Profile Name Color: 0099ff
Mini-Profile Text Color: 00e64d
|
Post by KirbyMaster0519/RainTracer on May 23, 2017 7:01:40 GMT -5
Most.....generic critique ever. You don't just tell someone to start a new style. It's like telling Optical to stop making Modernistic levels when he's good at making the designs. That's not really constructive criticism by just saying, "Yep. Knobbel has his rainbows. Rustam has his art. Terrible level because there's nothing new." 1) im not calling the level terrible. anyone who thinks that that last sentence was anything but a joke is pretty dumb lol. i will concede that it was a pretty poorly executed joke on my expense. i'm only saying the level has creators who build the exact same thing for every part they make. look at dudex's, hinds' or vlacc's part for example and compare it to their parts in other collabs or other levels. after seeing the same thing so many times, one can only kinda get bored when i see effectively the same part here. 2) "It's like telling Optical to stop making Modernistic levels when he's good at making the designs." this isnt on the same league as rustam or dudex yet. optical makes unique things from his style and each of his levels are explorations on what he can do with modernism. people like dudex have nearly the exact same structures, block design, glow style and colour combinations for every level / level part lol 3) by using the word """generic""" to describe my critique, it kinda proves you have no idea what the word means and are just using for the sake of using it. (I was sleepy and kinda couldn't think properly. This usually happens to me because I have so much school and have to keep up the A's. Stress.)since i can logically assume you are using the term generic in a negative and derogatory light, the definition of generic in that context is "lacking imagination or individuality, and being predictable or unoriginal". looking at the comments on this thread, im the only one who has raised this complaint, valid or not. thus my critique is the very ANTHITHESIS of generic. we can say on the other hand, using this definition, that, for example, "featured levels are generic", or dare i say, "every dudex, hinds or rustam collab part is generic." in conclusion, i dont think most of these creators made a bad level. i think most of these creators just made parts that didnt fully explore the limitations of their styles. im not saying that the level is bad or that the creators are bad or that the parts are bad because of a lack of originality. neither am i saying that everyone is unoriginal here. aquatius's part was pretty sweet honestly and its something i've never seen from him before. i'm just saying that if the creators here had pulled an Optical and fully explored the depth of their styles, this collab would have been so much better. until then lets agree to disagree. Ah, I see. I actually do get what you're saying. While there are some parts I disagree, I do understand where you are trying to get. I thought you were aiming at something else, but it does seem slightly more logical than last time. |
|
|
|
Post by durianhead on May 23, 2017 8:12:54 GMT -5
1) im not calling the level terrible. anyone who thinks that that last sentence was anything but a joke is pretty dumb lol. i will concede that it was a pretty poorly executed joke on my expense. i'm only saying the level has creators who build the exact same thing for every part they make. look at dudex's, hinds' or vlacc's part for example and compare it to their parts in other collabs or other levels. after seeing the same thing so many times, one can only kinda get bored when i see effectively the same part here. 2) "It's like telling Optical to stop making Modernistic levels when he's good at making the designs." this isnt on the same league as rustam or dudex yet. optical makes unique things from his style and each of his levels are explorations on what he can do with modernism. people like dudex have nearly the exact same structures, block design, glow style and colour combinations for every level / level part lol 3) by using the word """generic""" to describe my critique, it kinda proves you have no idea what the word means and are just using for the sake of using it. (I was sleepy and kinda couldn't think properly. This usually happens to me because I have so much school and have to keep up the A's. Stress.)since i can logically assume you are using the term generic in a negative and derogatory light, the definition of generic in that context is "lacking imagination or individuality, and being predictable or unoriginal". looking at the comments on this thread, im the only one who has raised this complaint, valid or not. thus my critique is the very ANTHITHESIS of generic. we can say on the other hand, using this definition, that, for example, "featured levels are generic", or dare i say, "every dudex, hinds or rustam collab part is generic." in conclusion, i dont think most of these creators made a bad level. i think most of these creators just made parts that didnt fully explore the limitations of their styles. im not saying that the level is bad or that the creators are bad or that the parts are bad because of a lack of originality. neither am i saying that everyone is unoriginal here. aquatius's part was pretty sweet honestly and its something i've never seen from him before. i'm just saying that if the creators here had pulled an Optical and fully explored the depth of their styles, this collab would have been so much better. until then lets agree to disagree. Ah, I see. I actually do get what you're saying. While there are some parts I disagree, I do understand where you are trying to get. I thought you were aiming at something else, but it does seem slightly more logical than last time. Fair enough, I was also writing the original post at 12am so its pretty hyperbolised and blown out of proportion, I do apologise for the miscommunication and misunderstanding caused. Thanks for the calm, collected reply honestly ;3; |
|
170 posts
Discord: zzzzzzzz
Clans: emotive hardcore
Creator Points: 0
Favorite Level: I don't play gd
Hardest Demon: what's gd
Mini-Profile Background: 000000
Mini-Profile Name Color: ffffff
Mini-Profile Text Color: fffff
|
Post by classic j dies an goes to hell on May 23, 2017 18:11:21 GMT -5
they should change the name because no one in that collab has played touhou so they shouldn't be allowed to name it after a touhou game :Thinking_Demon:
|
|
769 posts
Mini-Profile Background: {"image":"http://orig02.deviantart.net/285d/f/2016/287/2/1/sugary_space_by_star_abraham-daj88p4.png","color":""}
Mini-Profile Name Color: 0099ff
Mini-Profile Text Color: 00e64d
|
Post by KirbyMaster0519/RainTracer on May 23, 2017 19:07:09 GMT -5
they should change the name because no one in that collab has played touhou so they shouldn't be allowed to name it after a touhou game :Thinking_Demon: .......  |
|
|
|
Post by dCeru on May 23, 2017 20:40:18 GMT -5
Dudex part and Hinds part fit the song nicely
|
|
|
|
Post by ҠƦᶖҎƴ on May 24, 2017 0:01:42 GMT -5
Very subjective review: Aqua's part is good Jacob's part is meh Snowballys's part is meh Dudex's part is ok Speed's part is good Hinds's part is ok Darwin's part is ok Knobbelboy's part is good (best part deal with it) Vlacc's part is ok Rustam's part is meh Overall good level Don't get me wrong, Knobble's part is cool, but it doesn't seem to make an attempt to fit with the level like Darwin's or Hinds's parts. I may not be making any sense, but this is just my opinion. You can disagree with it.  |
|
4,759 posts
Favorite Level: Partystorm by ilZipperli
Mini-Profile Name Color: {"image":"https://managewp.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/spam.jpg","color":""}
|
Post by TheDotGamer on May 24, 2017 1:45:14 GMT -5
It's a really solid megacollab, not too difficut and almost everyone delivers here, but Hinds' part is a bit underwhelming Sadly, all the comments in the verification video and in the level will just be "Knobbelboy's part is SO GOOD, HES GOD LIKE SJRKDJEIEJDJFJU JAJAJAJA" If Knobbelboy is god, why would he make God Eater :thinking: He wants to eat himself Looks AMAZING btw |
|
120 posts
Creator Points: 0
Favorite Level: X by TriAxis or Lonely Travel by FunnyGame
Hardest Demon: Fire Temple by Michigun
Mini-Profile Background: {"image":"","color":"54e619"}
|
Post by jackfettgames on May 24, 2017 5:21:03 GMT -5
Very subjective review: Aqua's part is good Jacob's part is meh Snowballys's part is meh Dudex's part is ok Speed's part is good Hinds's part is ok Darwin's part is ok Knobbelboy's part is good (best part deal with it) Vlacc's part is ok Rustam's part is meh Overall good level Don't get me wrong, Knobble's part is cool, but it doesn't seem to make an attempt to fit with the level like Darwin's or Hinds's parts. I may not be making any sense, but this is just my opinion. You can disagree with it. Sorry, I didn't know that Knobble didn't know the theme. |
|
|
|
Post by hinds on May 25, 2017 17:27:11 GMT -5
1) im not calling the level terrible. anyone who thinks that that last sentence was anything but a joke is pretty dumb lol. i will concede that it was a pretty poorly executed joke on my expense. i'm only saying the level has creators who build the exact same thing for every part they make. look at dudex's, hinds' or vlacc's part for example and compare it to their parts in other collabs or other levels. after seeing the same thing so many times, one can only kinda get bored when i see effectively the same part here. 2) "It's like telling Optical to stop making Modernistic levels when he's good at making the designs." this isnt on the same league as rustam or dudex yet. optical makes unique things from his style and each of his levels are explorations on what he can do with modernism. people like dudex have nearly the exact same structures, block design, glow style and colour combinations for every level / level part lol 3) by using the word """generic""" to describe my critique, it kinda proves you have no idea what the word means and are just using for the sake of using it. since i can logically assume you are using the term generic in a negative and derogatory light, the definition of generic in that context is "lacking imagination or individuality, and being predictable or unoriginal". looking at the comments on this thread, im the only one who has raised this complaint, valid or not. thus my critique is the very ANTHITHESIS of generic. we can say on the other hand, using this definition, that, for example, "featured levels are generic", or dare i say, "every dudex, hinds or rustam collab part is generic." in conclusion, i dont think most of these creators made a bad level. i think most of these creators just made parts that didnt fully explore the limitations of their styles. im not saying that the level is bad or that the creators are bad or that the parts are bad because of a lack of originality. neither am i saying that everyone is unoriginal here. aquatius's part was pretty sweet honestly and its something i've never seen from him before. i'm just saying that if the creators here had pulled an Optical and fully explored the depth of their styles, this collab would have been so much better. until then lets agree to disagree. You'd be right in saying that I never really tried much new with my part, except from a few designs that I hadn't used before :\ (I can't speak for the other people you mentioned though). I didn't have any remarkably unique ideas but I would still say that I managed to create something decent that I can say I'm happy with, which is what I think is the most important thing. Not everything has to be a blow-your-mind masterpiece (though, it sure is a bonus I guess). |
|
95 posts
Discord: CandyZamByzLOL #5743
Clans: Aftercution
Creator Points: 0
Favorite Level: Dark Travel
Hardest Demon: 28% Black Blizzard Working on ABP
|
Post by CandyZamByzLOL on May 25, 2017 21:33:20 GMT -5
knobbleboys part tho
|
|
562 posts
Clans: [CNN]
Hardest Demon: ffffff
Mini-Profile Background: ffffff
Mini-Profile Name Color: {"image":"https://secure.static.tumblr.com/5f1c7bb0562f67f5c99bc9735d73a42b/pfrqf7c/TdUoewnf9/tumblr_static_filename_640_v2.jpg","color":""}
|
Post by Zendayo on May 25, 2017 23:02:04 GMT -5
shit taste in touhou games
Perfect Cherry Blossom for life
|
|
|
|
Post by durianhead on May 27, 2017 1:16:57 GMT -5
1) im not calling the level terrible. anyone who thinks that that last sentence was anything but a joke is pretty dumb lol. i will concede that it was a pretty poorly executed joke on my expense. i'm only saying the level has creators who build the exact same thing for every part they make. look at dudex's, hinds' or vlacc's part for example and compare it to their parts in other collabs or other levels. after seeing the same thing so many times, one can only kinda get bored when i see effectively the same part here. 2) "It's like telling Optical to stop making Modernistic levels when he's good at making the designs." this isnt on the same league as rustam or dudex yet. optical makes unique things from his style and each of his levels are explorations on what he can do with modernism. people like dudex have nearly the exact same structures, block design, glow style and colour combinations for every level / level part lol 3) by using the word """generic""" to describe my critique, it kinda proves you have no idea what the word means and are just using for the sake of using it. since i can logically assume you are using the term generic in a negative and derogatory light, the definition of generic in that context is "lacking imagination or individuality, and being predictable or unoriginal". looking at the comments on this thread, im the only one who has raised this complaint, valid or not. thus my critique is the very ANTHITHESIS of generic. we can say on the other hand, using this definition, that, for example, "featured levels are generic", or dare i say, "every dudex, hinds or rustam collab part is generic." in conclusion, i dont think most of these creators made a bad level. i think most of these creators just made parts that didnt fully explore the limitations of their styles. im not saying that the level is bad or that the creators are bad or that the parts are bad because of a lack of originality. neither am i saying that everyone is unoriginal here. aquatius's part was pretty sweet honestly and its something i've never seen from him before. i'm just saying that if the creators here had pulled an Optical and fully explored the depth of their styles, this collab would have been so much better. until then lets agree to disagree. You'd be right in saying that I never really tried much new with my part, except from a few designs that I hadn't used before :\ (I can't speak for the other people you mentioned though). I didn't have any remarkably unique ideas but I would still say that I managed to create something decent that I can say I'm happy with, which is what I think is the most important thing. Not everything has to be a blow-your-mind masterpiece (though, it sure is a bonus I guess) well, fair enough on your part, I guess. not every part has to be a grindfury or your part in artificial ascent, and i'm totally fine with that. as long as you're happy with it its fine for you lol. personally, i felt your part was a little empty, but again, coming off from your other builds, that's kinda to be expected. Overall, your part isn't the worst or the least original, just a liiiitle underwhelming imo. But hey, as long as you're fine with it i am too. also sorry if this is a tad bit incoherent, for some reason the thing i wrote yesterday about this just didnt upload here for some reason. idk i can probably reclarify but its reaaaaaaallly late here and i need to go off lol |
|
