84 posts
Favorite Level: Venom - TheRM22
Hardest Demon: ffd0f2
Mini-Profile Background: ffb7e2
Mini-Profile Name Color: {"image":"","color":"70003f"}
|
Post by ~ [GD] n_Lev ~ on May 10, 2016 20:51:23 GMT -5
|
|
113 posts
Creator Points: 0
Favorite Level: Lost Legends by 123Ev4n
Hardest Demon: 000000
Mini-Profile Background: b648c2
Mini-Profile Name Color: http://i.imgur.com/oo4QNnC.jpg
|
Post by Tsukifuto on May 12, 2016 4:34:11 GMT -5
Gameplay: Neat gameplay. Moving objects were used correctly. Bad thing about the gameplay is that its too repetitive. 7/10
Music Sync: Almost perfect. There are just few parts that didn't sync well. 8/10
Design and decoration: Design and decoration is simple. Design was fine, but decoration was just too repetitive. It was the same thing
throughout the level, and it's a bit empty. 6/10.
Originality: x1
Overall Score:7/10-Decent
|
|
84 posts
Favorite Level: Venom - TheRM22
Hardest Demon: ffd0f2
Mini-Profile Background: ffb7e2
Mini-Profile Name Color: {"image":"","color":"70003f"}
|
Post by ~ [GD] n_Lev ~ on May 12, 2016 8:49:58 GMT -5
Gameplay: Neat gameplay. Moving objects were used correctly. Bad thing about the gameplay is that its too repetitive. 7/10 Music Sync: Almost perfect. There are just few parts that didn't sync well. 8/10 Design and decoration: Design and decoration is simple. Design was fine, but decoration was just too repetitive. It was the same thing throughout the level, and it's a bit empty. 6/10. Originality: x1 Overall Score:7/10-Decent Please tell me where was Gameplay too repetitive? When was music sync off? When was the level "empty"? |
|
113 posts
Creator Points: 0
Favorite Level: Lost Legends by 123Ev4n
Hardest Demon: 000000
Mini-Profile Background: b648c2
Mini-Profile Name Color: http://i.imgur.com/oo4QNnC.jpg
|
Post by Tsukifuto on May 12, 2016 9:51:11 GMT -5
Gameplay: Neat gameplay. Moving objects were used correctly. Bad thing about the gameplay is that its too repetitive. 7/10 Music Sync: Almost perfect. There are just few parts that didn't sync well. 8/10 Design and decoration: Design and decoration is simple. Design was fine, but decoration was just too repetitive. It was the same thing throughout the level, and it's a bit empty. 6/10. Originality: x1 Overall Score:7/10-Decent Please tell me where was Gameplay too repetitive? When was music sync off? When was the level "empty"? Where was the gameplay repetitive? 35%-45% and 50%-60%(50%-60% isn't TOO repetitive btw, but 35%-45% really is. Also percentage may not be accurate.) When was the music sync off? As a fairly easy level with a song that has a lot of sounds in it, it's very likely to have sync a bit off. Such as the cube/robot parts and there are some which I can't point. But it's impressive to have almost perfect sync with a fairly easy level. When was the level empty? Alright, as a simple level I can consider that being a bit empty is ok. But I think the score will remain the same because I forgot to mention the placement of some swirls on the top of some "pillars" with blending makes it look a bit messy. I hope you got your answers :/ |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on May 12, 2016 10:07:28 GMT -5
Alright, alright, I'll judge this tomorrow when I get home, fine, seeing as there's confusion or something @-@
|
|
|
|
Post by purplecoin777 on May 12, 2016 19:52:37 GMT -5
I'm not a level judge, but I still want to try and review some levels in hopes of becoming one, so here's a review:
Gameplay: 3.3/4
I really like the gameplay in this level, it's fun, varied, and flows nicely. The only things I don't like about it are the first coin and the pink orbs in the UFO.
Design: 3.0/4
Although the design is unique, simplistic, and looks nice, it is pretty repetitive as it stays the same style throughout the whole level. However, you did a good job slightly varying the designs and that increases the score by quite a bit.
Music Sync: 1.7/2
The music sync is almost perfect. Well done. My only complaint is the lack of flashes, with them only appearing in the first part.
Originality: 1.2x
This level is very original. Nothing much left to say here.
Suggestions:
[0:00] Make the colours inside those blocks start off black, as it looks weird to have them instantly disappear as the level starts.
[0:26] Nerf that coin, it's really luck-based and the space you have to go through to get it is really tight.
[0:42] Remove the part with pink jump orbs, I crashed into the wall above them twice without any way of avoiding it.
[0:08 - 1:15] Add flashes to the level. Since the music is upbeat, they would make the music sync score go up higher
Total score: 9.60 = Feature Worthy
This puts your level in Rank 5 of 9
(out of the levels I have reviewed)
Good luck on your next level!
The level leaderboard and more information about how I judge can be found here.
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on May 12, 2016 19:54:46 GMT -5
Gameplay: 8/10 Looks pretty funny, good job. However datwave coin and dat mini UFO orb spamming are way too hard for the level. Decoration: 9/10 Looks funny and fits with music. However every level looks like that in 2.0 Final: 7.2/10 Decent  |
|
84 posts
Favorite Level: Venom - TheRM22
Hardest Demon: ffd0f2
Mini-Profile Background: ffb7e2
Mini-Profile Name Color: {"image":"","color":"70003f"}
|
Post by ~ [GD] n_Lev ~ on May 12, 2016 20:58:43 GMT -5
Gameplay: 8/10 Looks pretty funny, good job. However datwave coin and dat mini UFO orb spamming are way too hard for the level. Decoration: 9/10 Looks funny and fits with music. However every level looks like that in 2.0 Final: 7.2/10 Decent Wha...? Just give me a second, I really don't this review. Your original post: "Gameplay: 9/10 Looks pretty funny, good job. However i found it a bit weird. Decoration: 9/10 Looks funny and fits with music. However every level looks like that in 2.0 Final: 8.1/10 Good "(don't ask me how I got that, I have my ways.) 1) why does 9 and 9 make 8.1...? 2) apparently my level is "funny"? What does that mean? 3)"Decoration fits the music, but every 2.0 level does that" and...? How is that bad? And now you new post: 4) for some reason which is not stated, the quality of the Gameplay lowered. 5)how do 8 and 9 make 7.2? That makes even less sense. 6)why is 7.2 "decent"? Can I see your judging scale? I hope you could give a more detailed review like the ones above you. |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on May 12, 2016 21:00:22 GMT -5
Gameplay: 8/10 Looks pretty funny, good job. However datwave coin and dat mini UFO orb spamming are way too hard for the level. Decoration: 9/10 Looks funny and fits with music. However every level looks like that in 2.0 Final: 7.2/10 Decent Wha...? Just give me a second, I really don't this review. Your original post: "Gameplay: 9/10 Looks pretty funny, good job. However i found it a bit weird. Decoration: 9/10 Looks funny and fits with music. However every level looks like that in 2.0 Final: 8.1/10 Good "(don't ask me how I got that, I have my ways.) 1) why does 9 and 9 make 8.1...? 2) apparently my level is "funny"? What does that mean? 3)"Decoration fits the music, but every 2.0 level does that" and...? How is that bad? And now you new post: 4) for some reason which is not stated, the quality of the Gameplay lowered. 5)how do 8 and 9 make 7.2? That makes even less sense. 6)why is 7.2 "decent"? Can I see your judging scale? I hope you could give a more detailed review like the ones above you. 4) Sorry, edited cruz did not noticed bugs EDIT: 5 and 1) Gameplay * Decoration ÷ 10 = Final rate (yeah, right now i seen that's wrong) 1-3 is NI 4 is Nearly Decent 5-7 is Decent 8 is good 9-10 is FW 3) Every 2.0 lvl has that decoration 2) Funny gameplay means funny to play. Funny decoration means i like it in some way. |
|
84 posts
Favorite Level: Venom - TheRM22
Hardest Demon: ffd0f2
Mini-Profile Background: ffb7e2
Mini-Profile Name Color: {"image":"","color":"70003f"}
|
Post by ~ [GD] n_Lev ~ on May 12, 2016 21:15:53 GMT -5
Wha...? Just give me a second, I really don't this review. Your original post: "Gameplay: 9/10 Looks pretty funny, good job. However i found it a bit weird. Decoration: 9/10 Looks funny and fits with music. However every level looks like that in 2.0 Final: 8.1/10 Good "(don't ask me how I got that, I have my ways.) 1) why does 9 and 9 make 8.1...? 2) apparently my level is "funny"? What does that mean? 3)"Decoration fits the music, but every 2.0 level does that" and...? How is that bad? And now you new post: 4) for some reason which is not stated, the quality of the Gameplay lowered. 5)how do 8 and 9 make 7.2? That makes even less sense. 6)why is 7.2 "decent"? Can I see your judging scale? I hope you could give a more detailed review like the ones above you. 4) Sorry, edited cruz did not noticed bugs EDIT: 5 and 1) Gameplay * Decoration ÷ 10 = Final rate (yeah, right now i seen that's wrong) 1-3 is NI 4 is Nearly Decent 5-7 is Decent 8 is good 9-10 is FW 3) Every 2.0 lvl has that decoration 2) Funny gameplay means funny to play. Funny decoration means i like it in some way. Can you please show me another level with that same exact decoration as in my level? |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on May 12, 2016 21:23:25 GMT -5
4) Sorry, edited cruz did not noticed bugs EDIT: 5 and 1) Gameplay * Decoration ÷ 10 = Final rate (yeah, right now i seen that's wrong) 1-3 is NI 4 is Nearly Decent 5-7 is Decent 8 is good 9-10 is FW 3) Every 2.0 lvl has that decoration 2) Funny gameplay means funny to play. Funny decoration means i like it in some way. Can you please show me another level with that same exact decoration as in my level? Ok, not the same but it does not unique like another judging person says... What is unique for is for example... FG's levels... Ok, there got a good point however i don't really like it how other levels. |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on May 13, 2016 2:49:42 GMT -5
Gameplay: Neat gameplay. Moving objects were used correctly. Bad thing about the gameplay is that its too repetitive. 7/10 Not enough information at all, and no suggestions for Lev to improve the level. No.
Music Sync: Almost perfect. There are just few parts that didn't sync well. 8/10 A few parts, tell me, which parts? Because it was pretty much 100% synced.Design and decoration: Design and decoration is simple. Design was fine, but decoration was just too repetitive. It was the same thing throughout the level, and it's a bit empty. 6/10. Block design varies a lot, so that's not repetitive, and the level is not empty at all. You didn't include any suggestions here either. Underrating things will not get you a good reputation as a judge.Originality: x1 "x1" Well I guess that the wave's gameplay wasn't original, and nothing else in the level is too. You're underrating this. And by that I mean A LOT.Overall Score:7/10-Decent How in the world is 7/10 "decent"? What? I don't understand.Gameplay: 8/10 Looks pretty funny, good job. However datwave coin and dat mini UFO orb spamming are way too hard for the level. How the heck can a level be "funny" without intending to be? And did you even play the level? Oh, I forgot, this is the Gameplay section isn't it? Well, how the heck can GAMEPLAY "look funny"?! And nothing to tell Lev about how to improve the level.Decoration: 9/10 Looks funny and fits with music. However every level looks like that in 2.0 "However every level looks like that in 2.0" I don't get this. There are tons of different styles in 2.0 and to be honest, if I looked in the Featured Levels section I wouldn't find more than 5 levels that look like this on the first three pages. And you're saying this is funny? Why?! Don't forget that you didn't add ANY suggestions for the level creator, Lev.Final: 7.2/10 Decent Gameplay: 8, Decoration: 9, oh yeah, sure, I'll give this a 7.2/10 because I don't know how to do Maths. Ugh. And again, how is 7.2/10 a "Decent"?! Alright, no offense you two, but your reviews are completely and utterly horrible. Comments in bold.
On with the review: -pretty decent review but not detailed enough- I would approve this if you gave more information... Write more next time! Keep it up! You'll get judge one day.  Gameplay: Really fun! However, KINDA like purplecoin777 said, you should nerf the orb spam. (Not remove it though, it's actually really fun!) The transitions are amazingly done and just, amazing use of moving blocks. Coins are nicely done and wave section is probably the part where I had the most fun. You should probably nerf the 2nd coin though, as most people have said, and try making less auto sections. 3.9/5 Decoration: Absolutely wonderful use of blending, amazing decorative use of moving blocks and a great amount of detail put into the level. You should add flashes or screen blackouts in some sections, and be sure to keep the block design up, it's amazing! There are no cutoffs, and great placement of items. Just wish that there was more variety in the type of pulsing objects, try making one go invisible while the other one pops up immediately as the colour changes, it'll be pretty cool. 4.2/5 Originality: Quite original gameplay ideas in there, such as the wave, and the block design is pretty unseen. You took a risk with the pillars and extra-blending in the entire level, and it pretty much paid off, to be honest. But however, some parts, such as the orb spam and the ball, are pretty much used a lot. I won't take too many points off though. 3.2/5 Atmosphere: Fun, upbeat, fast and basically just enjoyable in a lot of ways. Love it. Keep up the great work! I'd have liked it more if you added background pulses and more changes though. 3.4/5 Music Sync: Basically perfect, there's only 1 jump from the start that wasn't synced to be honest, and that was a jump pad! xD Just, keep making amazing syncs! 4.7/5 Bonus Points: Moving blocks are not abused and great gameplay ideas, I can see a lot of thought has been put into this. 2.1/5 Total score is 21.5/30 or 86/120. Belongs in Feature Worthy section. +Level Pick Tried my best not to be biased, think it paid off. Moving. |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on May 13, 2016 3:19:49 GMT -5
Gameplay: Neat gameplay. Moving objects were used correctly. Bad thing about the gameplay is that its too repetitive. 7/10 Not enough information at all, and no suggestions for Lev to improve the level. No.
Music Sync: Almost perfect. There are just few parts that didn't sync well. 8/10 A few parts, tell me, which parts? Because it was pretty much 100% synced.Design and decoration: Design and decoration is simple. Design was fine, but decoration was just too repetitive. It was the same thing throughout the level, and it's a bit empty. 6/10. Block design varies a lot, so that's not repetitive, and the level is not empty at all. You didn't include any suggestions here either. Underrating things will not get you a good reputation as a judge.Originality: x1 "x1" Well I guess that the wave's gameplay wasn't original, and nothing else in the level is too. You're underrating this. And by that I mean A LOT.Overall Score:7/10-Decent How in the world is 7/10 "decent"? What? I don't understand.Gameplay: 8/10 Looks pretty funny, good job. However datwave coin and dat mini UFO orb spamming are way too hard for the level. How the heck can a level be "funny" without intending to be? And did you even play the level? Oh, I forgot, this is the Gameplay section isn't it? Well, how the heck can GAMEPLAY "look funny"?! And nothing to tell Lev about how to improve the level.Decoration: 9/10 Looks funny and fits with music. However every level looks like that in 2.0 "However every level looks like that in 2.0" I don't get this. There are tons of different styles in 2.0 and to be honest, if I looked in the Featured Levels section I wouldn't find more than 5 levels that look like this on the first three pages. And you're saying this is funny? Why?! Don't forget that you didn't add ANY suggestions for the level creator, Lev.Final: 7.2/10 Decent Gameplay: 8, Decoration: 9, oh yeah, sure, I'll give this a 7.2/10 because I don't know how to do Maths. Ugh. And again, how is 7.2/10 a "Decent"?! Alright, no offense you two, but your reviews are completely and utterly horrible. Comments in bold.
On with the review: -pretty decent review but not detailed enough- I would approve this if you gave more information... Write more next time! Keep it up! You'll get judge one day. Gameplay: Really fun! However, KINDA like @purplegaze said, you should nerf the orb spam. (Not remove it though, it's actually really fun!) The transitions are amazingly done and just, amazing use of moving blocks. Coins are nicely done and wave section is probably the part where I had the most fun. You should probably nerf the 2nd coin though, as most people have said, and try making less auto sections. 3.9/5 Decoration: Absolutely wonderful use of blending, amazing decorative use of moving blocks and a great amount of detail put into the level. You should add flashes or screen blackouts in some sections, and be sure to keep the block design up, it's amazing! There are no cutoffs, and great placement of items. Just wish that there was more variety in the type of pulsing objects, try making one go invisible while the other one pops up immediately as the colour changes, it'll be pretty cool. 4.2/5 Originality: Quite original gameplay ideas in there, such as the wave, and the block design is pretty unseen. You took a risk with the pillars and extra-blending in the entire level, and it pretty much paid off, to be honest. But however, some parts, such as the orb spam and the ball, are pretty much used a lot. I won't take too many points off though. 3.2/5 Atmosphere: Fun, upbeat, fast and basically just enjoyable in a lot of ways. Love it. Keep up the great work! I'd have liked it more if you added background pulses and more changes though. 3.4/5 Music Sync: Basically perfect, there's only 1 jump from the start that wasn't synced to be honest, and that was a jump pad! xD Just, keep making amazing syncs! 4.7/5 Bonus Points: Moving blocks are not abused and great gameplay ideas, I can see a lot of thought has been put into this. 2.1/5 Total score is 21.5/30 or 86/120. Belongs in Feature Worthy section. +Level Pick Tried my best not to be biased, think it paid off. Moving. k, gonna improve it next time |
|
28 posts
Creator Points: 2
Favorite Level: Out of my friends: Periodic Surge (SquirrelBane, Featured) Out of normal levels: (I know this is generic, but) Reanimation
Hardest Demon: ffffff
Mini-Profile Background: ffffff
Mini-Profile Name Color: {"image":"http://i.imgur.com/6MKMWOs.gif","color":"000000"}
|
Post by undampedstraw on May 13, 2016 15:13:15 GMT -5
Im sorry, but i don't think this belongs in the featured section. i have seen WAY better levels in the put in the good levels or below. Im not going to give a review for this since all of this is pretty much said and done, but this post just spoke out to me :/
|
|
84 posts
Favorite Level: Venom - TheRM22
Hardest Demon: ffd0f2
Mini-Profile Background: ffb7e2
Mini-Profile Name Color: {"image":"","color":"70003f"}
|
Post by ~ [GD] n_Lev ~ on May 13, 2016 18:26:36 GMT -5
Im sorry, but i don't think this belongs in the featured section. i have seen WAY better levels in the put in the good levels or below. Im not going to give a review for this since all of this is pretty much said and done, but this post just spoke out to me :/ You're saying this level is bad, but you're not saying why. It's the equivalent of saying "this level is bad move to needs improvement!!!!!1!111!1!!!!!1!1!!!!11" |
|
![~ [GD] n_Lev ~ Avatar](http://storage.proboards.com/6138434/avatar/FZqZ8G8qRL8FUPZV7zs8.jpg)
